Mansfield Park (1999)

Mansfield Park: Directed by Patricia Rozema. With Hannah Taylor Gordon, Talya Gordon, Lindsay Duncan, Bruce Byron. Fanny, born into a poor family, is sent away to live with wealthy uncle Sir Thomas, his wife and their four children, where she’ll be brought up for a proper introduction to society.

“This isnu0026#39;t an awful movie. Itu0026#39;s quite watchable. Some of the acting, especially from Pinter is excellent.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eBut the rest resembles those films made from classic novels in the 30s where no one concerned in making it had time to read the book. A quick treatment by a college student, a quick script conference, then off we go. Rozema has almost no idea of what the book is about but is entirely unembarrassed by her ignorance in her interview on the DVD.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eAusten fans donu0026#39;t have to wait long to discover just how far off the wavelength she is. The first contact between Sir Thomas and Fanny is a reproof for running through MPu0026#39;s corridors shrieking like a banshee. Lines are taken from Mary Crawford in the book and given to Fanny in the film. Howu0026#39;s that for missing the point? One by one characters appear looking no more recognisable than if they were appearing in a literary celebrity edition of Scooby Doo.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eI agree with other reviewers that if the film was called something else and the characters had different names, it would be impossible to trace itu0026#39;s origins to Austenu0026#39;s book which is definitely not a conventional love story about bright young things getting together having overcome a few obstacles.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eThereu0026#39;s very little to choose between the morals of Rozemau0026#39;s characters, so nothing of the catastrophic descent into the abyss is associated with the production of Loveru0026#39;s Vows, nor do we have any glimpse of Rushworth and Crawford vandalising Sotherton. Mrs Norris is one of the most deliciously evil creations in literature – Rozema reduces her part to a few lines. Thomas Betram is a u0026quot;modernu0026quot; artist – yikes! William Price, Fannyu0026#39;s brother and one of the key relationships in the book, is missing altogether. Susan, her sister, has been reading too many Style magazines.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eMansfield Park might have been a bit like this had it been written by Georgette Heyer or even Jackie Collins. As an Austen adaptation it is execrable. But itu0026#39;s so far off the mark, that as something else entirely, itu0026#39;s not all that bad. Maybe they should just change the title.”