The Tempest – Der Sturm (2010)

The Tempest – Der Sturm: Directed by Julie Taymor. With Felicity Jones, Jude Akuwudike, Reeve Carney, David Strathairn. Shakespeare’s epic play is translated from page to screen, with the gender of the main character, Prospero, changed from male to female.

“The Tempest is not the most riveting drama, the larger realization is after all a certain weariness with it. This is given to us as a magician who halfway through the story abandons his powers of illusion, who after conjuring to him the characters and plotting the story of revenge pauses to reflect on the emptiness of the endeavor. Itu0026#39;s still powerful then, because we are all Prosperos alone in our island with the thoughts we conjure up to inhabit.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eIn Shakespeareu0026#39;s time, the inspiration for Prospero must have likely come from the scandalous topic of John Dee, the communion with spirits and visions through crystals certainly point at that as well as more broadly the notion of a benign magic. Magic since well before Dee and up to Crowley has tried its best to mask in so much hoopla what other spiritual traditions make clear from the start: that man is an embodied consciousness with the ability to direct that consciousness to vision. Shakespeare no doubt understood this was exactly his own art, a rich and complicated magic of conjured vision in peoplesu0026#39; minds.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eSo if this is to be powerful, you have to adopt a very intricate stance. Show both the power of illusion as vision and, contradictory, the emptiness of it, the fact it is underpinned by an illusory nature of reality. Greenaway masterfully did this in his Prospero film by having Prosperou0026#39;s creation of the play as vision, the vision lush and wonderful, and yet at every turn shown to exist on a stage.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eTaymor is too earnest to strike this stance, in fact judging by the cinematic fabrics here she seems unsure of what direction to follow. She is an earthy woman so intuitively builds on landscape, volcanic rock under our feet. Pasolini could soar in this approach judging from his mythic films, her approach is too usual and without awe. The magic is also too ordinary. A few movie effects cobbled together in earnest as something to woo simple souls like Trinculo. Compared to the novel richness of Greenaway this feels like discarded Harry Potter work. And the cinematic navigation is without any adventure, as if Taymor didnu0026#39;t believe there was anything for her to discover outside the play, to conjure up in the landscape itself by wandering to it, so she never strays in visual reflection.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eMirren conveys the reflection as best she can, but that is all here, too little.”