Phantom der Oper (1943)

Phantom der Oper: Directed by Arthur Lubin. With Nelson Eddy, Susanna Foster, Claude Rains, Edgar Barrier. An acid-scarred composer rises from the Paris sewers to boost his favorite opera understudy’s career.

“Before writing a film article on Claude Rains for CLASSIC IMAGES (December 2000), I took another look at u0026#39;Phantomu0026#39; to appraise his performance. Heu0026#39;s one of those rare actors who can make you feel sympathy when he plays the ill-treated violinist so that you understand why he turns into u0026#39;The Phantomu0026#39;. His performance is just one asset of this handsome technicolor adaptation of the famous story. Why carp about the changes made for this version? It stands on its own as an entertaining melodrama studded with operatic sequences that give it added dimension. Nelson Eddy has never been in better voice and Susanna Foster is certainly up to the demands of her singing role. The comic aspects of the story are a bit overdone and the only weakness of the film is giving Eddy and Edgar Barrier silly routines as they compete for the hand of Foster. Aside from that, this can still be enjoyed as a horror story set against the Paris Opera background. The sets are rich and detailed. Understandably, the film won Academy Awards for color cinematography and color art direction. Edward Wardu0026#39;s haunting score was also nominated and contributes greatly to the overall enjoyment of the film. The horror is muted in this version–but the rich musical highlights are a compensation. Absorbing entertainment.”