The Forbidden Room (2015)

The Forbidden Room: Directed by Guy Maddin, Evan Johnson. With Roy Dupuis, Clara Furey, Louis Negin, Udo Kier. In this non-linear amalgamation, submarine crewmen and a woodsman wend their way through a voyage of odd experiences.

“In a time when Hollywood seems completely incapable of creating anything original (not b/c itu0026#39;s all been done before, which I would argue is the case for music, but b/c Hollywood is run by non-creatives who only look at dollar signs and are terrified of risk), the unique works of Guy Maddin stand out like a precious stone. Love him or hate him, you have to admire his dedication. For the layperson, his films are often hard to access or decipher. In this way, his works remind me of the late great David Lynch (heu0026#39;s not dead, but seemingly retired). I am not as well-versed in Maddin films as I am with Lynch, but Iu0026#39;m also not the first to point out their similarities. For one, they have a very similar soundscape. This film in particular employs Lynchu0026#39;s standard drones of dread, synthesized melancholic strings, and industrial sfx. However, Maddin adequately stakes out his own territory, as well. His employment and recreation of various vintage film stocks is somehow both convincing and unique. His tendency to embrace distortion and outdated special effects goes further than Iu0026#39;ve seen with any other filmmakers.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eAs far as plot, the film employs a standard concept, the story within a story, but it also takes this concept further than Iu0026#39;ve ever seen done before. The narrative structure is in fact two nesting russian dolls, presented one after the other. The framing story (not counting the bookends which feature a hilarious Louis Negin giving bath-taking advice) concerns a group of men marooned inside a submarine, unable to resurface due to a large block of melting jelly which will explode if depressurized. But then the impossible happens. Not unlike the supernatural events in Tarkovskyu0026#39;s Solaris, a lumberjack suddenly appears in the submarine, unaware of how he got there. From this scenario, we enter the story of the lumberjacku0026#39;s last memories. Before this concludes however, weu0026#39;ve gone off on another tangent, another story within the story. And thus continues the narrative, falling further and further down the rabbit hole, until finally, as if coming up for air, we reverse directions and begin to zoom out, resolving one story at a time, until weu0026#39;re back in the submarine. However, as I mentioned before, this is only one of two plunges the movie makes before we receive a conclusion to the tail of the submariners.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eThe titular Forbidden Room refers, I believe, to the Captainu0026#39;s Quarters, but also derives from a 1914 silent film now considered to be lost. Which leads me to the second big concept of the film. All of the stories, vignettes, and tangential meanderings are based on silent films which can no longer be viewed, as they have either been lost or destroyed. This part I didnu0026#39;t know going into the movie, though I wish I had, for it adds an interesting element to the often surreal storylines. For a moment, when the film was just beginning, I had a tinge of worry that it would be an exercise in style over substance, and I know many would agree with me on this. However, as the different concepts were picked up and dropped, I became engrossed in the tone shifts, in turns erotic, surreal, melancholy, and humorous, and realized I was being swept up in the narratives.u003cbr/u003eu003cbr/u003eFor those uninitiated in an intentionally bombastic visual style, the Brechtian effect of constantly being reminded that you are watching a film may prove too difficult to overcome. But for those of you who can enjoy an attack on the senses, such as with Natural Born Killers, while still managing to pierce through the surface level and immerse themselves in the plot buried underneath, this film might be for you. And if it isnu0026#39;t, donu0026#39;t despair. I readily admit, this is one of the harder films to access. Just donu0026#39;t make the mistake of writing a belligerent review employing extremes and absolutes. Weu0026#39;ve already got plenty of those, as typified by most of the reviews for The Forbidden Room. Although, I have to admit, there is a certain comical irony to seeing a reviewer call a film impenetrable, inaccessible, undecipherable, only to be followed by a glowing review written by someone who has seemingly done the impossible – deciphered a plot!! There is definitely a plot here, and though it was a struggle at times, I managed to retain my awareness of which stories were inside of which, which stories had finished and which had yet to be resolved, etc. So give it a shot. Hopefully this review has, to some extent, prepared you for what you are about to see. And if it isnu0026#39;t working for you, turn it off. But please, for the love of god, donu0026#39;t tell me about the hours you invested which you will never get back. Nobody gives a ratu0026#39;s bottom about your stupid precious hour, especially when you continued to waste time by writing an asinine review about your experience.”